Updated list:
Round 1: Fish Fly Fever (this thread)
Round 2: Skate or Die 2
Round 3: Yo! Noid
Round 4: Valence
Round 5: Breaker
Round 6: Mr. Driller
Round 7: Libble Rabble
Round 8: GigaWing
Round 9: Pac-Man Championship Edition ND (NES Demake)
Have we ever done some sort of game of the month club? Not chasing scores, but similar to this in that someone picks a game and everyone who cares to tries it out and discusses it. Kind of trying to capture what sometimes happens when a game is new and a lot of people are playing it at once and sharing discoveries and progress as we go. But maybe with older, somewhat-obscure games.