So I’ve been watching The X Files a lot recently and I feel like it is just so overwhelmingly, surprisingly good that I don’t really know how to deal with it. Of course there bad episodes and a lot of general corniness, but overall I’ve been surprised by how well it holds up. If anything it is even better as a kind of artifact of a very particular time in USA.
I keep wanting to type this very long thing about how the show is probably the best ‘total package’ encapsulation of, uh, the sort of aesthetic/epistemological reality of the early 1990’s, by combining vague visual/thematic allusions to things like Cops, Unsolved Mysteries, Weekly World News, Twin Peaks etc. with its general ethos of … naive paranoia? I don’t know. Like, the most implausible thing about the show looking at it today is the idea that the FBI would ever grant anyone access to any kind of information like that. The government is both the hero and the antagonist, and it seems like a lot of the drama in the overarching mythology is trying to figure out exactly how and why that is possible. I think a show depicting a government conspiracy these days would have to be approached from the outside, or in the very least by someone who had a specific agenda against the government, rather than from people who are executing the commands of one part of the government faithfully, while apparently simultaneously pissing off the “shadow government” or whatever. It ends up being nonsense, but it works because the particular reality it inhabits is also kind of nonsensical. I keep wanting to draw some deeper significance from the fact that the show premiered just a few months after the whole Waco thing, and consider that in relation to the current non-starter “uprising” in Oregon, but I don’t really know how to sound that smart about it.
Anyway
I feel like a much easier thing for me to express is that the show would really be 10x worse without David Duchovny as Mulder. I don’t know if he really should get get all credit for this, but the fact that all of his lines suggesting the existence of UFOs or aliens are whatever are delivered with this kind of self aware sarcasm makes the whole character so much more palatable. It would be way stupider if he was just a total die hard believer in the cause. But having him realize how silly all of it sounds really goes a long way.