Ok so…last year I played Elite Force all the way through. The aesthetics were pretty great, but nearly every level overstayed it’s welcome and the back half of the game was really repetitive and filled with super generic arenas fighting generic enemies in generic envriments. The enemy AI is super boring.
Half-Life 2’s constantly changing scenarios, weapon set, and excellent enemy placement kicks it’s ass.
That’s not even getting into my confusion that HL-2’s short fast physics puzzles are somehow apparently worse than the absolutely awful jumping puzzles of Half-Life 1.
And Ravenholm was great. It felt weird and that was a good thing. The constantly changing scenarios in HL-2 are it’s greatest strength. You’re almost never just fighting combine in a boring room, you’re always encountering them in new places and new contexts.
Like…HL-2 is a good shooter. It’s better than most raven games and I love Raven’s stuff. But Raven’s stuff can be really sloggy, and wildly uneven.