Finished watching the netflix Haunting of Hill House show, and it’s one of the most cowardly pieces of media I’ve ever encountered. I didn’t expect it to be as good as, or even similar to, the book. But with the like, 95% fresh rating and rave reviews from viewers, I thought it would be like…not extremely frustrating?
Long long rant, and also mega spoilers
I want to lay out as much of this as I can. The premise is that a family moves into a house in the uh, 80’s I think. And one night, some really really bad shit goes down. Now 20+ years later, all the surviving members of the family are miserable and haunted by various ghosts, both literal and figurative.
The first 8 episodes are mostly about setting up Evil House, in between familial drama. It does this via liberal time-hopping, and it’s very good at keeping this up. Scenes are tied together thematically and episodes tend to focus on one character to keep things straightforward. And it goes a long way to show the deleterious effect even being in this house has. It’s successful in this! And it has some really great episodes.
The one with the funeral is an all-timer for me, capturing perfectly the awkwardness inherent to death, the gracelessness that people handle it with, and how disastrous it can be to a group of people. It also does this faux single-take thing that I found incredibly distracting, but otherwise I thought it was great.
Also, the reveal that Nell (poor Nell) was haunting herself throughout time was really good. Like, it’s just absolutely miserable in this really resonant and cool way. There are several moments like this but that’s definitely the coolest reveal. And it speaks a lot to the both literal and figurative non-linearity of time. Humans live as much in their memories and hopes and fears as they do the present, and this is just more literally true for ghosts.
The thing that is very clear for the first 8 episodes is that becoming a ghost in the house sucks so bad. It’s so bad. Constant delusion and torture and confusion. It’s bad!! I cannot emphasize how bad it is to be a ghost in this house.
Anyway, the last two episodes are really fucking frustrating. Episode 9 is the big reveal of what happened on a certain night in the past. This takes the show from “Ghosts are a sort of ephemeral presence and the house is really the issue” to “Ghosts will tell you to kill your children, and then you’ll try to kill your children.” I hate how literal this is - just let things be vague! It also takes time to lay out origins for like, half of the ghosts, which is like. Why? I don’t need this level of detail.
Then the last episode is just like, the most cowardly shit I’ve ever seen. All the family is in the house again, and it’s trying to digest them. It does this by uh, giving them hallucinations and then explaining the origin stories for every previously unexplained ghost that’s been in the show in fairly great detail. Very annoying.
And the last 15 minutes are the fucking deal breaker for me. It becomes this thing about how the mother and her one dead kid are trapped in this house, but it’s not that bad actually. And the dad sacrifices himself and is also in the house, and that’s fine it’s all fine. And it ends by showing the very literal mechanics of how the house works - if you die in the house, you become a ghost. That’s it. You don’t have to live in the house for a long period of time, there’s no corruption, none of that. You die there, you’re a ghost now. Congrats.
And this is all supposed to be a good thing!! Like something about a family united through time, and all this shit, and it’s gross! Like, be brave enough to have a bad ending or even a mixed ending. Who demanded that this show (which is for the record not family friendly) have this sappy, undermining ending???
(I imagine the higher ups at netflix tbh)
The show opens with the famous opening lines from the book, specifically:
No live organism can continue for long to exist sanely under conditions of absolute reality; even larks and katydids are supposed, by some, to dream. Hill House, not sane, stood by itself against its hills, holding darkness within; it had stood so for eighty years and might stand for eighty more. Within, walls continued upright, bricks met neatly, floors were firm, and doors were sensibly shut; silence lay steadily against the wood and stone of Hill House, and whatever walked there, walked alone.
This sets up the themes for the book and show perfectly. Whatever walked there, walked alone, There is no connection, no family, no dignity in this house. It is a bad place.
And then at the very end, they repeat this, except they change the last line to:
…whatever walked there, walked together.
Excuse me??
Anyway, I fucking hated this show at the end, which is really frustrating because the first 8 episodes were a perfectly fine B+ to A- affair. I haven’t been able to stop thinking about how much it frustrated me since then. Cannot recommend it.