My current stick that I use for everything with the help of Brook Super Converters is just
a PS3/4 Hori Real Arcade Pro. V 2017 edition (JP only, fixed the lag problem w/ original RAPV boards) with the stock “Hayabusa” lever and buttons replaced with Sanwas.
Before this I used a variety of things. Chronologically from the earliest mists of time:
Well okay I mean back in the day I used
Wico Bat Handle for C64 (and Amiga?)
Damn solid, lookit that thick steel lever in there. (
image source)
Dreamcast - TopMax Enforcer
Rackety plastic, awful but the best thing I knew. (
image source) Weirdly angled buttons worked surprisingly well for Bangai-O.
Dreamcast - Capcom vs. SNK ASCII Stick FT, SNK version
Coming back to this after 12 years in 2017, the optical lever was incredibly stiff; guess you gotta keep those babies lubricated or something. And in retrospect, the buttons weren’t very good. At the time though it was a huge step up from anything I’d had at home before, but I’d never quite thought the lever was super great–a bit nebulous, not enough physical feedback for my liking I guess.

PS2 - Capcom vs. SNK 2 ASCII Stick FT2, SNK version
Buttons still a bit mushy but base a bit better, kind of a step up.

GC - Hori Soul Calibur II Arcade Stick
Not great, lever was all right maybe.
PS3 - Hori Real Arcade Pro. 3
The base wasn’t ideal but still it was actually something you could put Sanwa stuff in easily so I finally had some actual arcade parts to flail on.


PCE - Hori Fighting Stick PC
Went through a bunch of stuff when I came to the PCE way late, most of it pretty bad. This thing was a steel-sheeted tank. You could probably cut yourself on some of those edges. Lever pretty good, buttons not great but better than they looked maybe. Slope of the cold hard base not really ideal.